ACL Graft Types Compared: Patellar vs Hamstring vs Allograft

Patellar Tendon Autograft (Bone-Tendon-Bone)

The patellar tendon graft takes the middle third of your patellar tendon with small bone plugs from your kneecap and shinbone. Pros: Bone-to-bone healing (fastest integration), strongest initial fixation, gold standard for competitive athletes. Cons: Anterior knee pain (kneeling discomfort) in 10-20% of patients, slightly higher risk of patellar fracture, donor site pain during recovery.

Hamstring Autograft

Uses your semitendinosus and gracilis tendons (inner thigh hamstrings). Pros: Less anterior knee pain, smaller incision, less kneeling discomfort, good for non-athletes and recreational athletes. Cons: Slower healing (soft tissue-to-bone, no bone plugs), potential hamstring weakness (usually temporary), slightly higher re-tear rate in young athletes.

Quadriceps Tendon Autograft

Uses a strip of your quadriceps tendon above the kneecap, with or without a bone plug. Pros: Growing in popularity, thick strong graft, less anterior knee pain than patellar, good for revision ACL surgery. Cons: Newer technique (less long-term data), potential quad weakness, some surgeons less experienced with this option.

Allograft (Donor Tissue)

Uses cadaver tissue (patellar tendon, Achilles, or tibialis anterior from a tissue bank). Pros: No donor site pain, shorter surgery, good for older/less active patients, revision cases, or multi-ligament reconstructions. Cons: Higher re-tear rate in young athletes (2-4x higher), disease transmission risk (extremely rare), slower biological incorporation.

Comparison Table

Factor	Patellar Tendon	Hamstring	Quad Tendon	Allograft
Re-tear rate (young athletes)	5-7%	8-12%	5-8%	15-25%
Anterior knee pain	Higher	Lower	Low	None
Return to sport	6-9 months	6-9 months	6-9 months	9-12 months
Best for	Competitive athletes	Recreational athletes	Revision surgery	Older/less active patients

Frequently Asked Questions

Which ACL graft is best for athletes?

Patellar tendon autograft is considered the gold standard for competitive athletes who need to return to cutting/pivoting sports. It has the lowest re-tear rate and strongest initial fixation.

Which graft has the fastest recovery?

All autografts have similar overall recovery timelines (6-9 months). Allograft may allow earlier range of motion but has a slower biological incorporation and higher failure rate in active patients.

Can my surgeon use my own tissue?

Yes — patellar tendon, hamstring, and quadriceps grafts all use your own tissue (autograft). This is preferred for most patients, especially young athletes, due to lower re-tear rates.

Does the graft type affect long-term outcomes?

For most patients, all autograft options provide good long-term stability. The main differences are donor site symptoms (knee pain, hamstring weakness) and re-tear risk for high-demand athletes.

Find a Knee Surgeon Near You

Search 45,377 knee surgeons across 50 states.

Find Knee Surgeons Browse All Procedures